Why are you silent?
According to Eric Partridge, this term dates from the mid-nineteenth century in both England and the United States and was one of several phrases used in addressing a child who, after getting into trouble, refused to answer questions. The literal meaning “why are you silent?” is quite far-fetched, so it obviously comes from the grown-up’s invention of some bizarre circumstance that prevents the child from speaking. There is an analogous French idiom, “Je donne ma langue au chat,” meaning “I give up; I have nothing to say.”
Related and Similar Terms
- The cat got your tongue? — This insinuates that someone is unusually silent, often implying that they are withholding truth.
- Mum’s the word — A quirky way of advocating secrecy.
- Tight-lipped — Someone who is generally very secretive or reserved.
- Button your lip — A humorous directive to stop talking.
Synonyms
- Silent
- Speechless
- Mute
- Quiet
Antonyms
- Loud
- Talkative
- Vocal
- Expressive
Humor-Filled Quote
“A closed mouth gathers no foot.” — Anonymous
Suggesting Literature, Books, Songs, Poetry, and Movies
- Silence by Shūsaku Endō — A poignant novel that explores themes of faith and communication.
- Shh! We Have a Plan by Chris Haughton — A delightful children’s book on the art of silence and surprise.
- “The Sound of Silence” by Simon & Garfunkel — A classic song that captures the profound nature of quiet moments.
- The Quiet American by Graham Greene — An intriguing novel blending politics and personal vendettas.
Inspirational Thought-Provoking Farewell
Much like the complexities of language, silence holds its own enigmatic power — it can speak volumes even in its apparent absence. As we explore these curious curations, may we embrace the depths beyond mere words.
